Kaneohe Marine Under Fire for Iraq Puppy Video

Iraq Puppy VideoA YouTube video showing American soldiers tossing a puppy off a cliff in Iraq has set off a firestorm of protest online, and a 22-year-old Marine stationed at Kaneohe has become a ‘figure of hate‘ around the world.

KITV called the incident “terribly upsetting,” and, like other news outlets, broadcast only a portion of the video. Most early coverage refrained from naming the man in the video, who is addressed as “Motari” in the clip. But KHON’s Monday night report featured screenshots of Digg and other online fora that prominently featured the name David Motari.

Indeed, while the video only garnered mainstream media attention recently, the collective online mob had been at work for some time. Web sleuths identified Motari, tracked down his family’s home address in Washington, figured out whom he married and when (and her MySpace page), and found various online profiles, including one on an Asian dating site and another on the Bebo social network (which was set to private after dozens of angry comments and threats were posted).

Well before anyone was able to go on record about the video, the “cyber lynching” was underway. The people-powered search site Mahalo already has a page devoted to David Motari.

This morning, the Honolulu Advertiser named Motari in its report, saying the Marine Corps has confirmed that he is with the 1st Battalion, 3rd Marine Regiment at Kane’ohe Bay and that he returned to Hawaii in October from a seven-month deployment in Iraq.

“This is a shocking and deplorable video that is contrary to the high standards that we set for every Marine,” said Kaneohe base spokesman Maj. Chris Perrine, who said an investigation is under way. He also acknowledged that the Marine Corps is concerned with Motari’s safety, as well as the other two men that apparently played a part in making the video.

As disturbing as the video is, the amount and intensity of the attention it has been getting has also earned criticism. While forensics experts have already been enlisted by the media to hypothesize whether the video could be faked (Snopes’ says the validity of the video is “Undetermined“), critics and skeptics are dismayed that animal lovers are distracting attention from more egregious acts by American forces in Iraq.

And no, not just cruel acts against other animals.

3 Responses

  1. Captain America says:

    It is my understanding that the iraqi insurgents are raising these dogs to deliver bombs in suicide terrorist missions against the marines. Isn’t that a factor here? This is a deplorable act of animal abuse on part of the iraqi insurgents. In fact, these terrorists gave the marine no other choice but to preempt a terrorist strike by removing the threat. As usual, the liberal media and the bleeding hearts are all over this. I remind them that if it wasn’t for this proud soldier protecting their freedom, they wouldn’t be in such a position of privilege to insult true american Heros.

  2. cw says:

    i can’t bring myself to watch this video . at all. but i unfortunately found myself at doris duke watching the MOST AWFUL film about the soldiers in iraq. a mockumentary called “Redacted” that has so much brutal truth surrounding the soldiers, sometimes on deployment number 3 or 4, that are pretty much over it. their anger, fatigue and constant criticism turned them from human beings in to creatures capable of horrific acts. the film is obviously a bit dramatic but this situation makes me think of that film and how bad i feel for the military doing their duty and following orders and eventually driving themselves mad.

    captain america, you DO have a point but come on. what kind of person can murder an innocent bystander, rape an insurgents daughter, or throw a puppy over a cliff…. seriously

  1. June 12, 2008

    […] Motari, the Hawaii marine who was engulfed in controversy over a video clip posted to YouTube in March, has been expelled from the service. The video showed […]

Discover more from Hawaii Blog

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue Reading